skidder:
jdel:
Cab drives into the side of coffee shop on 1st Ave and 3rd St. No reported fatalities, but at least 1 person was taken to the hospital with serious but non-life threatening injuries.
JAMES DEL INVESTIGATES
This story has been posted everywhere, but let’s review what we know (and what was repeated among multiple news sources):
A cab was going north on First Avenue with at least one passenger. Around that time, a Jeep was traveling west on East 3rd Street and making a quick right turn onto First Avenue. Some witnesses claim the Jeep ran a red light.
The cab, unable to avoid the Jeep, swerved and hit the other vehicle… but then also crossed the parking lane, the bike lane (hitting and injuring two cyclists) before jumping the sidewalk and crashing into/through the front window of The Bean - also hitting a customer inside who was badly injured.
Let’s say the Jeep was totally at fault. This doesn’t explain how a late-model compact SUV taxicab with anti-lock brakes managed to go over 100 feet from the time of seeing the crossing vehicle to stopping… through the intersection, across a parking lane, across a bike lane, across the sidewalk… with multiple energy-absorbing collisions (Jeep, cyclists, curb, trashcan) along the way! At most, without impacts, the cab should have traveled 75 feet.
OH, WAIT, MAYBE THE CAB WAS SPEEDING. After all, the passenger in the back of the cab broke her teeth on the plexiglas divider in at least one of these collisions, indicating that a nearly full-speed collision happened as one of the collisions along the way.
What’s worse, this is a really big intersection, and in most cases you’d have a lot of time to react to a vehicle jumping out from East 3rd… The Bean is on the complete opposite side of the avenue from where traffic emerges from East 3rd, and there’s a bus lane and parking lane separating the traffic flow from that emerging side of East 3rd… it would be really hard to get in a full-speed accident in that intersection if you were traveling at the speed limit, and even harder to end up in a shop window. Of course, if you do not hit the brakes, or if you are already speeding, this is absolutely possible.
Would you believe that the commenters on the news stories linked are trying to blame the bike lanes for this mess? Of course they are. Eliminate the bike lanes and speeding, careening cabs will no longer be a problem. No one ever got hit by a cab before Janette Sadik-Khan started messing with the city.
In reality, before we reconfigure any bike lanes, we need to address the problem of crazy traffic on the streets. Our streets and intersections are designed for something like this to NEVER happen, even if a vehicle does slide through a red light. That’s why we have curbs, parking lanes and wide intersections. The fact that this cab crashed into a storefront - and could have killed people - should be a serious indicator to the police that traffic laws are being routinely broken by avenue traffic, especially taxicabs. The speed and erratic behavior of traffic in Manhattan is putting everyone in danger. When will we get serious about addressing it?
(via iaminlikewithmybike)